The release of Hong Kong Diploma of Secondary Education results marks an important turning point for many young people. As a university lecturer involved in admissions interviews, I was asked to help assess applicants’ suitability for a programme.

The responsibility felt heavier than I had expected. An interview is brief, yet the judgement that follows can influence a student’s next opportunity. That imbalance of time and consequence demands humility.

Judgement with care

Applicants arrive with different educational opportunities, communication styles and levels of confidence. A polished answer does not always indicate the greatest potential, just as nervousness does not indicate a lack of ability. Interviewers must look beyond performance while still applying fair and consistent criteria.

Structured questions, shared scoring guidance and independent review can reduce individual bias, but no process is entirely neutral. We must remain alert to how our assumptions about language, personality or experience affect our interpretation.

A responsibility, not a power

Admissions decisions should not feel like the exercise of personal power. They are an entrusted responsibility carried out on behalf of the university, the profession and the applicants themselves.

The experience reminded me to approach every interview with preparation, curiosity and respect. Even when an applicant is not offered a place, they deserve a process that is transparent, consistent and humane.