A correct answer can be reassuring. It can also conceal a great deal.
The student may understand the principle, recognise the relevant evidence and know how to adapt the decision. Or they may have remembered a sequence, copied a familiar pattern or arrived at the answer without understanding why it works.
In physiotherapy and other health professions, that distinction matters. Graduates will eventually make decisions that affect real patients. We need evidence not only that they can reach an answer, but that they can explain and defend the reasoning behind it.
Correct performance can still hide a misconception
Imagine asking a student to measure elbow extension with a goniometer. The student places the axis over the lateral epicondyle, aligns the stationary arm with the humerus and aligns the moving arm with the radius. The final measurement is correct.
Assessment complete? Perhaps not. A few focused questions can reveal whether the learner understands the measurement principle or has simply remembered the procedure.
- Why did you choose the lateral epicondyle?
- Why is the stationary arm aligned with the humerus?
- What error would occur if the axis shifted?
- How might swelling or body composition affect landmark identification?
- How would you adapt if the patient could not assume the standard position?
A short viva can make thinking visible
A focused educational viva can reveal reasoning, uncertainty and misconceptions that a checklist or final answer may miss. The aim is not to catch students out. It is to make their thinking visible.
Instead of asking only, ‘Where does the axis go?’, we can ask, ‘Why is that the appropriate landmark?’ Instead of asking only for a normal range, we can ask how the patient's presentation changes the interpretation.
The second question demands connection and judgement, not recall alone.
Explanation is evidence of understanding
A familiar learning principle is that trying to explain an idea clearly exposes the parts we do not yet understand. A learner who can teach a concept, justify a decision and respond to a follow-up question is providing stronger evidence of understanding than one who reproduces a memorised sequence.
This does not make factual knowledge or technical accuracy less important. It shows whether the learner can connect knowledge to action.
Technology can ask the next question
Imagine a virtual goniometry activity. The student positions the goniometer correctly. Before progressing, the system asks them to explain why they selected the lateral epicondyle as the axis.
The learner speaks or types a short response. An AI tutor does not supply the answer; it asks a bounded follow-up question about alignment error, patient positioning or interpretation.
Technology is then doing more than marking right or wrong. It becomes a questioning layer that helps expose the learner's reasoning. This idea could extend the existing Elbow Goniometry Challenge from procedural placement towards explanation and clinical judgement.
But a viva is not automatically fair
Oral explanation needs careful design. Unstructured questioning can reward confidence, language fluency or familiarity with an examiner rather than the intended clinical reasoning.
A defensible approach should align questions with the learning outcome, use standardised prompts and clear criteria, train assessors, and provide reasonable adjustments or alternative response modes where required. Explanation should strengthen the evidence for a judgement, not introduce a new source of ambiguity.
The question worth keeping
Perhaps one of the most valuable questions after a correct answer is: ‘Can you talk me through your reasoning?’
Sometimes the explanation confirms deep understanding. Sometimes it exposes a misconception. Either outcome is useful, because education is not simply about reaching the right answer. It is about understanding why that answer is right, when it might be wrong, and how the decision should change when the situation changes.