At a recent teaching and learning conference, artificial intelligence dominated the programme. Many presentations explained what generative AI is and demonstrated the latest tools. Those introductions were useful, but I left feeling that higher education now needs a more demanding conversation.
AI is already part of students’ and educators’ daily lives. The central questions are therefore about implementation and consequence: When does AI strengthen learning? When does it weaken independent thought? How should assessment change? What evidence should guide adoption?
Moving from novelty to educational purpose
A tool should not be adopted simply because it is impressive. We need to begin with the learning outcome, the needs of the students and the professional standards of the discipline. Only then should we ask whether AI offers an appropriate method.
For health professions education, this distinction is especially important. Students must develop clinical reasoning, communication, ethical judgement and accountability. AI may help them practise or receive feedback, but it cannot carry professional responsibility for them.
Questions for the next conference
The most valuable discussion is no longer whether AI will enter education. It is how educators can shape its use with care, evidence and a clear sense of purpose.
- How can assessment distinguish supported learning from uncritical dependence on AI?
- What forms of AI literacy do students and staff need?
- How do we protect privacy, equity and academic integrity?
- Which uses improve learning according to evidence rather than enthusiasm?